Boisseau, the full simulation.
A family-owned chain of DIY and garden centres on both sides of the Rhine, where shelves run out of de-icing salt at the first frost and overflow with bulbs at the end of the season. The case followed on this page, de-icing salt for the Fribourg-en-Brisgau store, the week of the first frost.
A family-owned chain of DIY and garden centres on both sides of the Rhine, where shelves run out of de-icing salt at the first frost and overflow with bulbs at the end of the season.
Every store has the right stock before the first frost.
- Boisseau is a family business operating eight DIY and garden centres in Strasbourg, Mulhouse, Freiburg im Breisgau, and Basel. It employs two hundred and fifty people, and each store has its own department managers, from gardening to tools.
- Orders are placed weekly, based on the previous year's sales and department managers' intuition. At the first frost, de-icing salt runs out in Freiburg im Breisgau while sitting idle in the Mulhouse stockroom.
- At the end of the season, unsold gardening stock piles up. In France, the law has banned its destruction since 2022, requiring every French store to find a second life for it.
- An agent forecasts weekly sales for each store, department by department, using sales history and weather forecasts. For French stores, public Météo-France data has been free of charge since 1 January 2024. The agent also factors in promotions and public holidays in each country.
- It then suggests restocking, as well as transfers between stores when one lacks what another holds in excess. Department managers receive these suggestions on Monday mornings, complete with the rationale for each, and approve or adjust them.
What remains with the department managers
Department managers decide on every order and transfer. Buyers negotiate with suppliers directly, and the agent alters no pricing.
- Shelf stockouts during peak periods
- Backroom stock at the end of the season
- Suggestions accepted without adjustments
- Transfers between stores
Unsold gardening stock
At the end of each season, the agent identifies unsold items across each store. For French stores, it suggests a donation to a charity or collection by a reuse centre.
Each store manager decides where unsold items go.
Supplier orders
The agent prepares purchase orders from approved restocking requests and tracks supplier confirmations, flagging any delay.
Buyers send each order and negotiate terms on their own.
In-store advice
Sales staff consult an assistant on their phone to find a technical spec sheet or a replacement product, in both French and German.
Sales staff advise the customer directly, and the assistant never interacts with the customer.
Staffing for peak weeks
The agent alerts managers to weeks when sales will rise, from the first frost to sunny weather, so they can plan staffing.
Each manager sets schedules themselves, in accordance with their country's labour laws.
de-icing salt for the Fribourg-en-Brisgau store, the week of the first frost
The winter's first frost, before and after.
- Forecasting
- The department manager orders as they did last year, without knowing when the frost will hit.
- The agent forecasts a sharp rise in salt sales for the week, based on weather data and sales history.
- First workstream
- Store stock
- Nobody knows that the Mulhouse stockroom is overflowing with salt.
- The agent compares stock across all eight stores and identifies the surplus in Mulhouse.
- First workstream
- The recommendation
- The department manager places an urgent order with the supplier, who delivers too late.
- The agent recommends a transfer from Mulhouse to Fribourg-en-Brisgau, along with the rationale and quantity.
- First workstream
- The decision
- The order goes out without anyone reviewing it.
- The department manager approves or adjusts the recommendation on Monday morning.
- First workstream
- End of season
- Unsold spring bulbs remain in the stockroom until summer.
- The agent identifies unsold items and suggests a donation for the French stores.
- Workstream 2
- Supplier orders
- Supplier delays are only discovered upon delivery.
- The agent tracks each confirmation and flags every delay to the buyers.
- Workstream 3
- Reading sales
- It reads sales every day for each store, department by department.
- Reading weather data
- It retrieves the weather forecast for each city, using public data from Météo-France for French stores.
- Forecasting
- It forecasts sales for the following week, including promotions and public holidays.
- Comparing stock levels
- It compares the forecast with stock on the shelves and in the stockroom for each store.
- Recommending
- It recommends replenishment and inter-store transfers, each with its rationale.
- Department managers approve or adjust.
- Preparing purchase orders
- It prepares purchase orders based on approved replenishment.
- Buyers send each order.
- Learning from adjustments
- It records every adjustment made by department managers and takes it into account the following week.
- Reporting
- Each month, it prepares a review of out-of-stock items and dormant stock, store by store.
- POS software
- Sales for each store, department by department.
- Read-only
- Inventory management software
- On-shelf and stockroom inventory across the eight stores.
- Read access, and preparation of purchase orders
- Weather forecasts
- Forecasted weather for each city, including public data from Météo-France.
- Read-only
- Commercial calendar
- Planned promotions and public holidays for each country.
- Read-only
- Department managers' portal
- Weekly recommendations, along with their rationale.
- Writing recommendations, approval by department managers
- Leadership
- Sets replenishment rules alongside us and selects the next workstream.
- Department managers
- Approve or adjust each replenishment and transfer recommendation.
- Buyers
- Send purchase orders and negotiate directly with suppliers on their own.
- Store managers
- Decide what to do with unsold stock and set staff rotas.
- The FDE
- Leads the engagement and writes agent rules alongside the team. They are accountable for every agent.
- Forecasting agent
- Forecasts sales for each store, department by department.
- Replenishment agent
- Compares stock levels and prepares replenishment and transfer recommendations.
- Ordering agent
- Prepares approved purchase orders and tracks supplier confirmations.
- Monitoring agent
- Compares forecasts with actual sales weekly and flags any recurring discrepancies to the FDE.
- The forecast is inaccurate.
- Every recommendation comes with its rationale, and the department manager adjusts it. The agent factors in each adjustment the following week.
- A transfer empties a store.
- The agent maintains a minimum stock level set by leadership in each store, and the department manager approves every transfer.
- An order goes out without review.
- The agent prepares purchase orders, and only the buyers send them.
- Prices change without agreement.
- The agent has no permissions over pricing, neither at checkout nor with suppliers.
- Sales data is leaked.
- The agent reads sales figures without the ability to export them, and every access is logged.
- We measure the baseline from the past season, including stockouts during peak periods, end-of-season dormant stock, emergency orders and inter-store transfers. Leadership sets the replenishment rules alongside us.
- The agent forecasts in parallel with department managers for three weeks, without sending them anything, and we compare its forecasts with sales.
- Garden department managers receive recommendations in two stores, then across all eight.
- We compare against the baseline and choose the next workstream with leadership.
- On-shelf stockouts during peaks
- Days an item is out of stock on shelves during peak weeks, compared to the baseline season.
- Stockroom inventory at season end
- Seasonal items still in the stockroom at the end of the season, store by store.
- Recommendations accepted without adjustment
- Share of recommendations approved as is by department managers.
- Inter-store transfers
- Transfers that prevent an emergency order, tracked in the inventory management software.