Steelyard, the full simulation.
A Portland-based online shop for second-hand outdoor gear, where every item waits for days before being catalogued and listed for sale. The case followed on this page, a rain jacket received from consignment with a tear on the sleeve.
A Portland-based online shop for second-hand outdoor gear, where every item waits for days before being catalogued and listed for sale.
Every item gets its listing upon arrival.
- Steelyard buys second-hand outdoor gear from individuals and takes items on consignment, from rain jackets to tents, reselling them online after inspection. Its Portland workshop employs eighteen people, and orders ship across the United States.
- Every item requires a complete listing, detailing the brand, size, measurements, and any visible defects. Two employees write them manually, and gear piles up in the workshop waiting to be listed online.
- Buyers then ask the same questions about the true condition of items, and items are returned when their condition falls short of the listing's description.
- The employee photographs the item from multiple angles, including the label. An agent reads the photos and drafts the listing, including the brand, size, measurements recorded by the employee, and visible flaws. It suggests a condition grade according to Steelyard's grading scale.
- The employee reviews the listing and assigns the final grade. They also note anything the photos cannot capture, such as a stiff zip. The agent then answers buyers' questions based on the listing and photos, introducing itself as an automated assistant.
What remains with the team
Employees alone assign the final condition grade to each item, and the team sets resale prices. Disputes and refunds are always handled by a team member.
- Time from item arrival to listing online
- Listings corrected by the employee
- Buyer questions prior to purchase
- Returns due to condition not matching the listing
Buying from individuals
Private sellers submit photos of equipment they want to sell via the website. The agent prepares an initial record and alerts the team buyer to items that match demand.
The team buyer sets each buyback offer.
Customer reviews
The agent drafts a response to each review and immediately forwards those reporting an issue to the team. Since 21 October 2024, an FTC rule has prohibited fake reviews, including those written by an AI.
A team member reviews each response, and Steelyard does not publish any review not written by a customer.
Returns sorting
Each returned item comes with the reason given by the buyer. The agent compares the item against its original record and prepares an assessment for the employee.
The employee decides on the refund and the outcome for the item.
Partner brands
Certain brands entrust Steelyard with their returns and repaired items. The agent prepares a monthly sales and returns update for each of them.
The sales team maintains the relationship with each brand.
a rain jacket received from consignment with a tear on the sleeve
A rain jacket with a tear, before and after.
- Arrival
- The jacket sits in a bin in the workshop until someone has time to describe it.
- The employee photographs it as soon as it arrives, including the label.
- First workstream
- The listing
- An employee writes the listing by hand, looking for the size and measurements.
- The agent drafts the listing from the photos and the measurements recorded by the employee.
- First workstream
- Flaws
- The tear on the sleeve goes unnoticed, and the listing promises perfect condition.
- The agent spots the tear on the photo and flags it in the listing.
- First workstream
- Condition
- Condition is decided on guesswork, varying from one employee to another.
- The agent suggests a condition rating based on the Steelyard rubric, and the employee sets the final condition.
- First workstream
- Buyer enquiries
- A buyer asks whether the jacket is truly waterproof, and waits two days for an answer.
- The agent answers using the listing and photos, introducing itself as an automated assistant.
- First workstream
- Returns
- The jacket comes back with a note from the buyer, and no one compares it to its listing.
- The agent compares the returned item to its original listing and prepares an assessment for the employee.
- Workstream 4
- Receive photos
- It receives the photos taken by the employee, including the label.
- Read the label
- It reads the brand and size on the label.
- Spot flaws
- It spots visible flaws and highlights them on the photo.
- Draft the listing
- It drafts the listing using the measurements recorded by the employee.
- Suggest a condition rating
- It suggests a condition rating based on the Steelyard rubric, along with its reasoning.
- The employee sets the final condition.
- Complete
- It adds to the listing anything the employee noted that the photos do not show.
- Answer buyers
- It answers questions using the listing and photos, introducing itself as an automated assistant.
- Disputes are escalated to a team member.
- Report
- It prepares a weekly summary of corrected listings and recurring questions.
- Workshop application
- Photos taken by employees and their notes.
- Read-only
- Online shop
- Listings of items put up for sale.
- Draft writing, publication by the employee
- Condition rubric
- The Steelyard rubric defining each condition level, from new to worn.
- Read-only
- Buyer messaging
- Questions asked prior to purchase.
- Read and reply
- Returns register
- Returned items and the reason given by the buyer.
- Read, and assessment preparation
- The founders
- Set the condition rubric and the agent rules together with us.
- Workshop employees
- Photograph each item and set its final condition.
- The team buyer
- Sets each buyback offer made to private sellers.
- Customer service
- Handles disputes and decides on refunds.
- The FDE
- Leads the engagement and writes the agent rules with the team. He is accountable for each agent.
- Listing agent
- Reads photos and drafts listings.
- Response agent
- Answers buyer questions using the listings.
- Returns agent
- Compares returned items against their original listing.
- Audit agent
- Reviews a sample of published listings and flags any discrepancy with the photos to the FDE.
- The listing invents a detail.
- The agent describes only what it sees in the photos or what the employee noted, and the employee reviews every listing.
- A flaw goes unnoticed.
- The employee sets the final condition and notes anything the photos do not show.
- A buyer thinks they are speaking to a human.
- The agent introduces itself as an automated assistant from its very first reply.
- A review is fabricated.
- Steelyard publishes only reviews from its customers. Since 21 October 2024, the FTC has prohibited fake reviews, including those written by an AI.
- A private seller's photo shows their home interior.
- The agent crops every photo to focus on the item, and the employee approves each published photo.
- We measure the baseline over one month, including time to list, listings revised after publication, buyer enquiries and returns due to non-compliant condition. Employees write the condition rubric together with us.
- The agent drafts the listings for jackets and backpacks, and employees review each one.
- All categories transition to the agent, except tents, which employees pitch before describing them.
- We compare against the baseline and select the next workstream together with the founders.
- Time between item arrival and listing
- Time elapsed between an item arriving at the workshop and its listing being published.
- Listings corrected by the employee
- Share of listings corrected by the employee prior to publication, along with the nature of the corrections.
- Pre-purchase buyer enquiries
- Questions received per listed item, compared against the baseline month.
- Returns due to condition not matching the listing
- Returns where the reason is condition inferior to what was stated in the listing.