Trumeau, the full simulation.
A young property trading firm missing out on deals due to a lack of time to analyse them. The case followed on this page, a four-room flat spotted on a Thursday evening in La Plaine.
A young property trading firm missing out on deals due to a lack of time to analyse them.
Every identified property comes with its analysis pack.
- Trumeau buys flats and small buildings in Marseille to renovate and resell. Two years old, the company relies on a network of building contractors. Its two partners handle everything, from sourcing to resale.
- The partners spend their evenings browsing property portals and property auctions. For each promising asset, they must gather local pricing, planning regulations, co-ownership documents and surveys, and good deals are snapped up before the analysis is finished.
- Every day, an agent identifies properties on portals and at auctions that match the partners' criteria.
- For each selected property, it compiles an analysis pack: comparable sales drawn from public DVF data, planning regulations, key points highlighted from general meeting minutes and surveys, and anticipated works. Questions to ask the vendor are prepared before the viewing.
What remains with the partners
The partners decide independently whether to buy and at what offer price, following their viewing. The agent makes no offers and contacts no vendors.
- Properties analysed per week
- Time from listing to analysis
- Viewings followed by an offer
- Difference between planned and completed works
Quotes and works monitoring
The agent consults partner contractors based on the works schedule, then monitors the progress of each workstream with photos and reports.
The partners choose the contractors and approve each quote.
Financing applications
For each purchase, the agent compiles the bank application pack, from the sales agreement to the works quotes.
The partners negotiate their financing themselves.
Resale
Once the works are complete, the agent prepares the listing with the new DPE and photos. It then responds to buyers and organises viewings.
The partners set the price and choose the buyer, and no photo misrepresents the property.
Resale turnaround time
Property by property, the agent tracks the five-year deadline attached to the property trader tax regime, and alerts the partners well before it expires.
The company's chartered accountant validates each tax position.
a four-room flat spotted on a Thursday evening in La Plaine
A four-room flat in La Plaine, from listing to offer.
- Spotting
- The partners discover it on a portal on Saturday, two days after it goes online.
- The agent spots it on the day of publication and sends it to the partners with an initial assessment.
- First workstream
- Neighbourhood prices
- The partners compare listings at a glance, without actual sales prices.
- The agent compiles comparable sales published by the authorities in the DVF data.
- First workstream
- The co-ownership
- The minutes of the general meeting arrive after the viewing, and a major vote on works goes unnoticed.
- The partners request the documents from the seller, and the agent highlights key points, such as approved works and ongoing disputes.
- First workstream
- The viewing
- The partners view the property without a list of questions.
- The questions to ask arrive before the viewing, along with anticipated works.
- First workstream
- The decision
- The offer is submitted too late, or without proper analysis.
- The partners decide alone, file in hand, whether to buy and at what offer price.
- First workstream
- The works
- Quotes pile up in email inboxes, and progress is tracked over the phone.
- The agent consults partner contractors and monitors progress, supported by photos.
- Workstream 2
- Monitor
- It monitors property portals and auctions daily, in line with the partners' criteria.
- Filter
- It sets aside properties outside the criteria and presents the others with an initial reasoned opinion.
- The partners select the properties to analyse.
- Compare prices
- It compiles comparable sales from public DVF data and benchmarks them against the asking price.
- Review planning rules
- It brings together local planning regulations and easements affecting the property.
- Review co-ownership records
- It identifies approved or upcoming works, reported arrears, ongoing proceedings, and the status of the maintenance plan from the minutes and building maintenance logbook.
- Estimate works
- It provides an initial range based on property surveys and the company's past workstreams.
- The partners finalise the scope of works after visiting the site with a contractor.
- Prepare the viewing
- It lists the questions to ask the seller and the key points to inspect on site.
- Deliver the file
- It delivers a comprehensive analysis file to the partners, fully supported by sources.
- The partners decide independently whether to buy and at what offer price.
- Property portals
- Properties for sale listed by private individuals and estate agencies.
- Reading public listings
- Auctions
- Notarial and court-ordered auctions announced in the region.
- Reading listings and auction packs
- DVF data
- Sales over the past five years, published by the tax authorities.
- Consultation
- The partners' tracking spreadsheet
- Monitored properties, offers, ongoing workstreams, and resales.
- Adding properties and updating statuses
- Company email
- Correspondence with agencies, notaries, banks, and contractors.
- Drafts, sent by the partners
- The two partners
- Select properties, conduct viewings, decide whether to purchase, and determine offer prices.
- Partner contractors
- View properties alongside the partners and quote for works.
- The notary
- Drafts legal deeds and addresses legal questions.
- The chartered accountant
- Validates the company's tax positions.
- The FDE
- Leads the project and is accountable for each agent.
- Monitoring agent
- Monitors property portals and auctions.
- Analysis agent
- Prepares the analysis files.
- Works agent
- Tracks quotes and workstream progress.
- Quality control agent
- Verifies that every figure in the file cites its source and flags discrepancies to the FDE.
- A comparison price is misleading.
- Each cited sale links back to its entry in the DVF data, and the agent flags non-standard sales.
- A co-ownership legal proceeding goes unnoticed.
- The agent reviews the latest minutes and the building maintenance logbook, stating clearly what could not be verified.
- The analysis pushes towards a purchase.
- The file presents risks before upsides, and the purchasing decision remains strictly with the partners.
- Seller data is misused.
- DVF data is used solely to compare prices, and the agent never seeks to identify a seller.
- The resale deadline is missed.
- The agent tracks the five-year deadline for each property and alerts the partners well in advance, and the chartered accountant validates each position.
- We measure the baseline over recent months, including properties analysed per week and the turnaround time between listing and analysis. The partners define their criteria and the file template alongside us.
- The agent analyses properties previously purchased by Trumeau, and we compare its files against what the partners discovered post-purchase.
- Monitoring launches across priority neighbourhoods, and each file is reviewed by a partner.
- Monitoring expands across the entire city. We compare performance against the baseline and choose the next workstream with the partners.
- Properties analysed per week
- Analysis files delivered to the partners each week, recorded in the tracking spreadsheet.
- Turnaround time from listing to analysis
- Time elapsed between the publication of the listing and the delivery of the file.
- Viewings followed by an offer
- Proportion of viewings after which the partners submit an offer.
- Variance between projected and completed works
- Comparison between the initial estimate in the file and the final cost of each workstream.